For Sale ads now allowed?????

Jim Haney

NAWCC Member
Sep 21, 2002
6,930
1,689
113
71
Decatur, TN.
Country
Region
This thread in the American Pocket watch forum has "for Sale ads at the bottom.

https://mb.nawcc.org/showthread.php...road-Grade-Pocket-Watch&p=1066194#post1066194

I reported it to the Moderator,and his response was ,

Dave Coatsworth}Hi Jim said:
As a moderator for 5 years I know the NAWCC policy on "For Sale" ads.

If this is allowed it sets a double standard, allowing "For Sale Ads", because they appear on the NAWCC web site.

Rules can be bent, if they conflict with the NAWCC's income for the ad revenue,is that the bottom line?
 

John Hubby

Senior Administrator Emeritus
Staff member
NAWCC Star Fellow
NAWCC Life Member
Sep 7, 2000
12,291
238
63
The Woodlands, TX
Country
Region
Jim, there has been no change in NAWCC or Message Board policy with regard to for sale ads, nor is there any conflict with that policy caused by the ads in Keith's blog link.

Generally, the NAWCC has 'for sale' ads on all its websites. These include Google managed ads as well as banner ads placed by NAWCC member-owned businesses. The ad revenue is a significant source of income for support of NAWCC's web presence and general operations.

>> The main NAWCC website has for sale ads including business advertisements for NAWCC member-owned businesses, announcements of Library surplus book sales, museum surplus sales, etc. NAWCC also publish a periodic auction summary listing links to current auctions in the U.S. and elsewhere.

>> The NAWCC website that specializes in watch news ( https://watchnews.nawcc.org ) has 'for sale' ads of the same types as found on the main NAWCC website. Keith's blog is a feature of the watchnews website and the ads that are on the website are shown on all pages including Keith's blog.

>> This Message Board has for sale ads in the banner of every page.

>> The Message Board rules do not permit individual users to post for sale ads for their own goods, link to any direct active sale venue, or make references to such sales.

As Dave explained, Keith is linking to the NAWCC watchnews website and not posting those ads himself. Any NAWCC website that a user here may link to will have ad content, will not be prohibited, and it not in violation of Message Board "for sale" ad policy.
 

Markus Harris

Registered User
Feb 2, 2009
1,243
8
38
Lancaster, PA
Country
Region
As Dave explained, Keith is linking to the NAWCC watchnews website and not posting those ads himself. Any NAWCC website that a user here may link to will have ad content, will not be prohibited, and it not in violation of Message Board "for sale" ad policy.
Also, the Google Ad Sense advertisements in the ad slots at the bottom of the various NAWCC pages utilize Google's predictive ad targeting based on the recent Google searches and browser history of the particular viewer.

Apparently, some individuals who viewed that blog post saw ads for Rolex watches, based on their recent browser history. Whereas I myself saw ads for a furniture warehouse and lawn care companies, based(again) on my recent browsing history.

That's how Google Ad Sense placements work.
 

Jim Haney

NAWCC Member
Sep 21, 2002
6,930
1,689
113
71
Decatur, TN.
Country
Region
Markus,
Yes, I understand how Google ad sense works that is why I see Rolex's "For Sale" when I click on the ads. So it is a trade off of the rules because they are considered advertising and exempt from the rules?

I am sure the revenue is necessary to help the NAWCC's expenses and advertising is good income, however the dividing line is that the ads do show watches for sale but as long as the NAWCC is being paid for it, that makes it OK.

Also because they are not listed on the MB directly but are ad links?
 
Last edited:

Markus Harris

Registered User
Feb 2, 2009
1,243
8
38
Lancaster, PA
Country
Region
So it is a trade off of the rules because they are considered advertising and exempt from the rules?
I don't see where any "rule" has been broken. At all.

Keith Lehman posted A LINK to another website. One that is run by the NAWCC, but which does not exist on this Message Board, and which is an entirely separate entity than this message board.

If a reader clicks on that link, they are then sent to a blog article on the other site. A site which has advertising at the bottom of the page.

I am unaware of any rule that specifies NAWCC MB users cannot link to external sites which happen to have incidental advertising on them. If there is such a rule, then we literally have tens of thousands of links on this board right now that are in direct violation of it.

Nor am I aware of any rule that states NAWCC websites, in general, cannot have incidental advertising on them.

If a user posts material in the body of a post here which directly advertises some extraneous commercial venture that is not specifically endorsed by the NAWCC, then the task falls to the moderators and admins of this board regarding whether or not to allow it to stand or to remove it. If someone posts a spam link to this board, the sole purpose of which is to advertise some extraneous product or service not formally endorsed by the NAWCC, then again, it is the responsibility of the admins and moderators here to decide whether or not it violates this board's "no spam" rules and to deal with it appropriately.

But in the case under discussion, an NAWCC employee has posted a link to an NAWCC-endorsed blog on a separate site that happens to have an ad module situated at the bottom of its pages. The ads aren't Keith's, no ad material (horological or otherwise) has been posted directly to this board, and the link points to an NAWCC sponsored website which technically makes that link the OPPOSITE of spam.

Again: I see no violation of this board's rules whatsoever.
 

Jim Haney

NAWCC Member
Sep 21, 2002
6,930
1,689
113
71
Decatur, TN.
Country
Region
Markus.
In my feeble mind when I click on a link and it shows me watches for sale, it is a rules violation.

You can justify it by calling it advertising, but when I look at the ads there are watches for sale and I reason I am seeing them is because I clicked on a link on this MB. It is true that it is another site, and not our MB, however it ends up being a link to watches for sale.

If it is allowed because it is advertising and we receive income for the ads so be it.

Rule:
Links, references, or discussions about active sales or auctions will be
removed.
 

Markus Harris

Registered User
Feb 2, 2009
1,243
8
38
Lancaster, PA
Country
Region
Mr. Haney,

We have essentially zero control over which ads Google Ad Sense displays on sites other than this one.

According to your logic, every link posted on this board to eBay - EVER - no matter if it's to an expired auction, or not - is a "rules violation" because it displays advertising that MIGHT display a watch for sale. Even if the only reason it displays an ad for a watch for sale is because YOUR browser history told it to display a watch ad, rather than an ad for something else (refrigerators, or whatever).

As I said, there are numerous links on this message board right at this moment to sites that contain external advertising, the content of which is NOT always the same and which has no connection with the site itself, and is not chosen by the author of the site. That is most definitely the case in this instance.

I fully accept Mr. Hubby's pronouncement on this matter. However, I will consider petitioning the ED about making an adjustment to the rules of this board to specifically accomodate situations of this sort.

Regards,

Markus Harris
 

bruce linde

ADMIN / MODERATOR
NAWCC Member
Donor
Nov 13, 2011
8,711
1,319
113
oakland, ca.
clockhappy.com
Country
Region
Please explain the difference in allowing us to place ads (paid ads) in the Mart but not on the MB.


you've responded to an older thread on the topic. there's a more current discussion going on here: https://mb.nawcc.org/threads/why-no-sales-allowed-on-mb-or-nawcc-online.151074/#post-1442877

the answer to your question, though, is the new mart forum is authorized and allowed by the organization that provides the message board. the MB is supposed to be primarily for education about all things horological. having a mart forum might allow the organization to generate some additional (and much-needed) revenue. opening up all forums to anyone posting ads would be akin to opening pandora's box. and, there is nothing to prevent you from buying ads now on the message board... check out dave coatsworth's ads in the sidebars of all pages. i don't know what he's paying, but he reports a major uptick in business since he began running the ads.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
166,352
Messages
1,449,405
Members
86,827
Latest member
kawasemi
Encyclopedia Pages
1,057
Total wiki contributions
2,911
Last edit
NAWCC Forums Rules by Steven Thornberry