doug sinclair
05-07-2004, 01:47 AM
o. c. kidd,
Are you able to post a picture of the Elgin? It must be marked with the grade number 543, I suspect, as I see no listing for that grade in my references. I rather suspect that it is a fairly modern watch. My 1915 Elgin materials list stops at grade 417. My guess would be 1940s or 1950s, if these grade numbers were used chronologically. When you are posting queries such as this one, you will likely generate more response if you give information such as serial number, etc. And particularly when dealing with a grade that you have found to not be listed anywhere, a picture. We pretty well all use the same reference material. Hopefully, putting this back at the top of the board will generate some replies.
I checked George Townsend's book on American watches. He lists 10-size Elgins, but they are all early key-winders. Are you sure on the size? With no list to refer to, how did you determine size? Is the particular serial number of the watch listed in any references that you checked?
Doug S.
Are you able to post a picture of the Elgin? It must be marked with the grade number 543, I suspect, as I see no listing for that grade in my references. I rather suspect that it is a fairly modern watch. My 1915 Elgin materials list stops at grade 417. My guess would be 1940s or 1950s, if these grade numbers were used chronologically. When you are posting queries such as this one, you will likely generate more response if you give information such as serial number, etc. And particularly when dealing with a grade that you have found to not be listed anywhere, a picture. We pretty well all use the same reference material. Hopefully, putting this back at the top of the board will generate some replies.
I checked George Townsend's book on American watches. He lists 10-size Elgins, but they are all early key-winders. Are you sure on the size? With no list to refer to, how did you determine size? Is the particular serial number of the watch listed in any references that you checked?
Doug S.