What would be a better quality pocket watch?

[Randy Becker]

I have been looking at some Columbus and Illinois pocket watches both sz18 and 15jewels open face circa 1880's. What would be a more reliable watch and easier to find parts for if something went wrong.Thanks Randy.

[terry hall]

AS an OpInIoN,

The Illinois, mainly from the higher production numbers... this 'should' make repair parts a bit more plentiful.

[DEVILDOG76]

Hi Randy,

Like Terry said Illinois watches are easier to find parts for and Alot of there parts are interchangeable with other Illinois Watches. I think a good Illinois is a better runner than columbus and also easy to work on. Go with the Illinois and I think you can't go wrong. I have a two 18 size bunn's 15j and one 17j in my collection and they keep great time. Try to get a Illinois that's listed as railroad grade at the time it was made. I hope thus helps and have a nice day.

Sincerely, Don

[RON in PA]

From what I've read Columbus watches were not known as first class watches in their day. I'd second what has been said about Illinois watches.

[Randy Becker]

Thanks for the help.I will go with the Illinois and get the Columbus later.I have only been buying Elgins,Walthams and Hampdens up to now.Thanks for the advice.Randy